Conditions Case - Nike Labor
The
problems
Nike
was facing three problems for which Nike was being vehemently criticized.
Originally, Nike was the pet cause of the leftists and now Nike bashing had
become America’s newest spectator sport.
Labour
conditions
The major
issues were child labour, slave labour and workers who toiled in unsafe and
inhumane work environments. Indonesian workers revealed that they were being
paid as low as 19 cents an hour. Women workers could only leave the company
premises even on Sundays without permission from the management.
Â
To save face,
Nike had involved auditing organizations like Ernst and young to study the
working conditions. The firm was paid to publish a good report and this was
soon found out by the activists who questioned the objectivity of these audits.
Also, Nike
involved a group of its employees whose sole focus was to help make things
better for those who were making the Nike products. This was increasing the
feeling among the activists that Nike is undertaking these fake measures to save
its face.
Age of
workers
Age of the
workers employed in the manufacturing units was an alarming problem. Although
Indonesia had worker protection legislation in place, widespread corruption had
made the laws essentially useless. Nike contractors were hiring under age
workers and at the same time providing them salaries with which their daily
needs could also not be fulfilled.
Leaked excerpts
from a internal Ernst and Young report suggested that there were serious health
and safety issues in Nike factories. Majority of workers suffered from
respiratory ailments due to poor ventilation and exposure to chemicals.
Wages
Workers
in this part of the world were paid very low. The wages were too little to
compensate for the efforts and the final product that was produced.
Nike
sought to diffuse the wage issue by simply ignoring and argued that this labour
situation was beyond their control. They continued arguing that the stark wage
difference was due to the painfully low standard of living of people in these
countries.
Key
Issues
Corporate culture
Corporate
culture is used to control, coordinate, and integrate of company
subsidiaries. However differences in national cultures exist contributing
to differences in the views on the management. Differences between national
cultures are deep rooted values of the respective cultures, and these cultural
values can shape how people expect companies to be run, and how relationships
between leaders and followers should be resulting to differences between the employer
and the employee on expectations.
Problems
arise in corporations because agents (top management) are not willing to bear
responsibility
for
their decisions unless they own a substantial amount of stock in the
corporation.
Like
most organizations, Nike was interested only in the bottom line and the profits
generated. There was no regard paid to the environment, the working conditions,
the wages paid, the general well being of the employees etc. When questioned
they shirked the working conditions to be the responsibility of the
contractors.
Problems of Ethics
Despite
the American law of fair labour practices of 1938, which prohibits child
labour, limits the working hours and establishes safe working conditions, Nike
chose to give a blind eye. Also to make matters worse it threatened the
contractors to move business elsewhere if they were unable to keep wages down.
They also ignored the widespread bribery to public officials. Also they
indulged in paying audit firms for a better audit.
Nike
had become the symbol of corporate greed and explotation.